Japan’s Failure to Protect Japanese-American Children from International Parental Kidnapping in Violation of the Hague Convention on Child Abduction

General information about the resource:

Language: English

What is it about?

The Hague Conference on Private International Law established the Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction in 1980 (Hague Convention) in response to the legal issues surrounding international parental kidnapping. Ninety-six countries, including the United States and Japan, have adopted the Convention as of 2016.

Before signing and ratifying the Convention in 2014, Japan was known as a “black hole” for abducted children of divorced parents because most kidnapped children taken to Japan were never seen again. Even after ratifying the Hague Convention, Japan continues to be non-compliant4 because its unique Family Register Act, Civil and Criminal Codes with respect to family law, and its Hague Convention Implementation Act all effectively lack joint custody, meaningful enforcement mechanisms, and adequate remedies for abandoned parents.

The American military presence in Japan creates unique custody issues for Japanese-American military families. For example, the seminal case of Toland v. Futagi held that US Naval Commander Toland could not gain custody of his daughter after his ex-wife kidnapped her from a U.S. military base in Japan. When his exwife later committed suicide, Toland attempted to gain custody from the child’s Japanese grandmother. However, the Japanese court declined to resolve the issue and the Maryland court similarly declined jurisdiction. In Savoie v. Martin, U.S. citizen Savoie could not retrieve his children from his ex-wife after she refused to return them from a visit to Japan despite a Tennessee court granting Savoie full custody. In both cases, the Japanese legal system failed to provide a remedy to the American military member when the kidnapping parent took physical control over the children despite the standing custody arrangement.

Japan’s Family Registry Act, Civil and Criminal Codes with respect to family law, and Implementation Act should be amended to better protect Japanese-American children of American military members and to comply with the Hague Convention, especially with respect to the Article “grave risk” and “consent” provisions. The Japanese Family Register Act, Civil and Criminal Code regarding family law, and Implementation Act fail to protect abandoned parents and kidnapped children, especially as experienced by American military members.

Part II of this provides the historical and legal background giving rise to this problem, the modern legal context in which this problem exists, and the applicable international law against which Japanese legal culture clashes.

Part III of this analyzes how Japan’s Family Register Act, Civil and Criminal Code in family law, and Implementation Act violate the Hague Convention.

Part IV of this provides recommendations to amend Japanese law and utilize international pressure so that Japan fulfills its obligations under the Hague Convention.

Part V of this Comment briefly concludes that Japan fails to comply with its obligations under the Hague Convention.

Other resources that might interest you

Japan Resources

実録公開! 有名離婚弁護士”子の連れ去り指示”の現場

2021年10月10日 本会は、離婚を考えているある女性が、有名な悪徳離婚弁護士に相談に訪れた際のやり取りを、本サイト読者の方からの情報提供により入手しました。その内容を、以下の通り公開します。 Contents 1. 「別居すれば婚姻費用がもらえるよ」 2. 「子供を連れて黙って家を出るんだよ」 3. 「会えないのにお金出す馬鹿いる?」 4. 「どうして離婚したいのかをまだ聞いてない」 5. 「急いで別居、離婚までは長く」 6. 「賢い奥さんは別居するだけであとはほっとく」 7. 「子供をダシにして生きなきゃダメ」 8. 「調停の前は面会交流をブロックできない」 9. 「養育費の10%を5年分いただきます」 10. 「わざと階段から転げてみるとか」 「別居すれば婚姻費用がもらえるよ」 (20XX年X月X日、有名悪徳離婚弁護士の事務所にて) 弁護士:(相談者が書いた質問表を見ながら)離婚した後は、どういうふうにしていこうと?(※太字は弁護士の発言。以下同) 相談者:ちょっと、まだ……。(※細字は相談者の発言。以下同じ) 今住んでるところは賃貸? 賃貸です。 結婚期間が短いから、分けるものが何もないっていう離婚だよ。 そう思ってます。 離婚するときには、子供とお金に関することを決めるんだけど、子供の養育費はもらえます。これは裁判所で、お互いの年収でほぼ機械的に算出されるから。あなたの場合、慰謝料はないし、年金分割も微々たるもの。 もし離婚するってなったら、親権は私が取りたいんですけど。 彼、あんまり子育てしてないんじゃない? 仕事から帰ってくるのが遅くて。帰ると子供に構ってはくれるんですけど。

Read More »

Anatomy of a kidnapping

The Anatomy of a Kidnapping – from ABC Australian Radio Posted on January 1, 2013 by Brian Prager      Rate This The Anatomy of a Kidnapping is a radio documentary by ABC

Read More »